Skip to content

Compare And Contrast Essay Tuesdays With Morrie

Comparing Mitch Albom's Tuesdays With Morrie And Leo Tolstoy's The Death Of Ivan Ilych

Love and Death in Mitch Albom's Tuesdays with Morrie and Leo Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilych

One story is distinctively American in its optimism and characteristic of the 1990's in its tone; the other shows the unmistakable disposition of nineteenth century Russia. The more recent book follows the actual life of a sociology professor at Brandeis University while the other explores a product of Leo Tolstoy's imagination. Tuesdays with Morrie and "The Death of Ivan Ilych" portray two characters who sit on opposite ends of the literary spectrum but who share the dark bond of terminal illness and advance knowledge of their deaths. One views the knowledge as a blessing and as an opportunity to make his final good-byes, the other writhes in pain and begs for an end to his vicious sentence of suffering. In the face of identical fates these two men show stark contrasts, all for the simple reason that only one of them found a way to love.

    Though illness stripped both Morrie Schwartz and Ivan Ilych of their hope for survival, their dissimilar lifestyles led each to a much different end. Morrie found himself in an overflow of compassion while surrounded by family, friends and colleagues. Ivan, on the other hand, found only the obligatory company of his wife and the painful awareness that no one really cared. Both characters ended their lives the way they lived them, as Ivan acknowledges: "In them he saw himself" (Ivn, 149). While Morrie poured himself into every moment of life and every relationship he pursued, Ivan skirted the dangers of emotion to live "easily, pleasantly, and decorously" (Ivn, 115). In the spirit of such an opposition, the two stories become somewhat like responses to each other. Morrie Schwatrz, proclaimed by his tombstone as "A Teacher to the Last" (Mor, 134), offers a textbook on the path to meaning that can be pointed directly at the rootlessness of Ivan Ilych.

    Before we can understand the varying fates of these two men we must examine the prior years of life that scripted them. Morrie Schwartz lived for people and the opportunity to welcome them into his heart. He took the time to pursue a relationship with the student that would one day write his dying testimony, he took the time to cultivate a fruitful marriage and he took the time to give his fullest attention to everyone he encountered. Morrie cast off the deceptions of status and wealth, instead devoting himself to his family, his students, and the bouncing rhythms of the dance floor. Above all else, Morrie Schwartz clung to his guiding principle, "love each other or perish" (Mor, 91).

    In the face of Morrie's overwhelming compassion and tenderness, Ivan Ilych presents an opposite lifestyle. After a pleasantly carefree childhood he turned towards ambition and pursued an ever-larger salary and an ever-increasing social rank. Ivan lived without values and without attachments, easily moving between cities and jobs. He cared little for the great...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Tuesdays with Morrie, by Mitch Albom

1164 words - 5 pages "Tuesdays with Morrie" is about an elderly man named Morrie Shwartz diagnosed in his seventies with Lou Gehrig’s disease. Morrie has always lived his life in his own fashion, taking his path less stressful. And continues to do so until his dying day. One of his former students sitting thousands of miles away in Michigan stumbled upon this episode of “Nightline” on the television by chance and most likely by fate. This student, Mitch Album,...

The Death Of Ivan Ilych Essay

1018 words - 4 pages In "The Death of Ivan Ilych", the setting for this novella begins in the law courts. The second home of the main character Ivan. The story is told to us by...

The Life and Death of Okonkwo and Ivan Ilych.

1852 words - 7 pages Leo Tolstoy and Chinua Achebe both write about characters that go through their lives doing everything they are supposed to do according to their respective societies. But in the end, they both realize that all they have done was not enough. While each of the protagonists' lives turn to grief, one fate was tragic while the other was pathetic. As they continued on their paths to "succeed", neither was able to predict the dangers that lay ahead...

"Tuesdays With Morrie" by Mitch Albom: Critical Thinking

1519 words - 6 pages 1. Yes, my opinion about Mitch did change as the book went on. As a young man in college, Mitch found a friend away from home. This friend happened to be

"Tuesdays with Morrie" a Modern Day Hero, by Mitch Albom

653 words - 3 pages "Tuesday's With Morrie" is about a dying professor's last lesson with his students. Morrie, the professor, is a wise old man with ALS or...

Wisdom in King Lear by William Shakespeare and Tuesdays with Morrie by Mitch Albom

1416 words - 6 pages Wisdom is a very valued and respected trait in our society and is associated with the elderly. In both King Lear by William Shakespeare and Tuesdays with Morrie by Mitch Albom, the protagonists were able to acquire wisdom after undergoing trials and tribulations. However, both these men began their quest as completely different people, polar opposites even. Morrie always emphasized the value of family and love, while King Lear saw these as...

The Christain Theme of Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich

539 words - 2 pages The Christain Theme of Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich       Tolstoy's The Death of Ivan Ilyich attacks the pursuit of material possessions.  The Ilyich family bases itself upon the unsure foundation of wealth.  As Ivan ascends the rungs of the corporate ladder, he acquires new possessions and articles.  After joining the Civil Service, Ivan buys "new fashionable belongings" at the "very best shops" to keep up appearances (100).  For...

Summer assignment for AP Psychology about the book TUESDAYS WITH MORRIE by MITCH ALBOM. About 5 pages long. Looks at text in big-picture life philosophy.

1371 words - 5 pages Mitch Albom1997Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing Group, Inc. Tuesdays with MorrieTuesdays with Morrie:An old man, a young man, and life's greatest lessonTuesdays with Morrie, by Mitch Albom, is a lesson book on living life. One may easily argue that this book has two separate authors, because there are two separate views to be seen within its pages. Author Mitch Albom tells the story of a young man who travels...

The relationship of individual to society in Tolstoy's "The Death of Ivan Illych."

1377 words - 6 pages By Sergio BenavidesWrote more than a century ago, "The Death of Ivan Illych" it shows an always contemporary dilemma, a question that possibly we all going to ask at some moment of our life .This question summarize the thought of the author and it drives the reader to ask themselves, as Ivan ask in the imagination of

Tuesdays With Morrie

2322 words - 9 pages Tuesdays with Morrie "We're Tuesday people," he said."Tuesday people," I repeated.The Book: By

Tuesdays with Morrie

992 words - 4 pages The focus throughout Tuesdays with Morrie was on life. Many might see it as the story of death, but it is actually the story life. Morrie might talk a little on how he meets death, but what he is talking about is living at the end of his life. Mitch writes, “Now here we were . . . . . . Dying man talks to living man, tells him what he should know.”(Albom, 133) When a timer is placed on Morrie’s remaining days, he obtains a dying man’s...

In Tuesdays with Morrie, the golden rule gets taken a step further: Don't just treat others as you'd treat yourself, but do a little better by them. Mitch and Morrie tag-team this life lesson to show us how important compassion is.

Morrie is aware of others in spades, and until his dying day, he teaches that loving and caring for other people is important. In fact, it's the most important thing you can do in life. And since actions speak louder than words, let's just point out that he puts this into practice on a daily basis. Mitch shows compassion as well, and although it's not as much a part of his personality as it is for Morrie, he shows us the benefit of being compassionate in simple actions. Mitch's decision to be there for Morrie, after all, is the reason that we have their story today.

Questions About Compassion

  1. Compare and contrast the different ways that Mitch and Morrie show compassion. Is one better than the other, or are they just different?
  2. Is compassion about feeling badly for other people, or is there something more involved?
  3. Compare Mitch and Morrie to what we know about their youths. Were they as compassionate back then as they are in their last class?